Harry is a fussy, older pug. He knows there is a selection of treats on the counter. The one he liked yesterday, offered today, may be refused. He likes these most days. This is good. I buy two bags of these because I know he will eat them. Nature Gnaws have good nutrition in them, so while I may allow myself to eat junk food sometimes, I don't feed Harry junk. Old dogs don't eat that much so the food has to be good for them. These treats are good.See full review