Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
Devin Perry photo
South Korea, Seoul
1 Level
669 Review
40 Karma

Review on High-Quality Prime-Line Astra KC10HD Safety Spring Door Closer – Simple Installation to Transform Hinged Doors into Self-Closing – Strong Diecast Construction (4-1/4” White, Non-Handed) by Devin Perry

Revainrating 2 out of 5

Is working? Somehow - please read if it works for *you* before purchasing.

This item was purchased to close a bedroom door that slides easily on the bedroom carpet. Depending on the level of resistance, it takes about 7-8 pounds of force to close (light pressure). I know I went out and got the force gauge from my store to check it out. The device was *unable* to function in order to shut it down. I wound it so tight it creaked like a bad take of tormented souls in a Halloween-themed haunted house, tight enough that pulling it out slipped my hand and ripped a fifty-cent hole in my work glove. as well as the dented door with a short silver metal lock. A common problem with the design is that the working push arm is too short to work with resistance. If you push it a little, it starts very slowly and then speeds up as it gains momentum. Try closing the door with about 3-4 inches of force on the hinges and see how hard you push. Unless the door is over a tile, or has absolutely *zero* resistance, or is extremely light (a very cheap hollow-core door might do), this block will struggle or attain a dangerous pulling force while permanently coiled in the spring. I suspect it will eventually fail rather catastrophically unless a lower bound on the settings is set. Installation is very simple and quick, which benefits the device. Removal is also very easy as is the patchwork to cover the 4 holes he made. Do not finally install the sliding plate on the door until you are sure that it works. Attach it in a different way. I used double sided tape, glad I did as I don't have a hole in the door now, just trimming. So if you're looking for a device that sounds like a scared cat sack every time you open a heavy door, or you have a very light, totally unencumbered door swing, this is the product for you.

Pros
  • Sturdy finish
Cons
  • Damaged