I've been looking for various replacement paddles for the Elite 2 controller because the OEM paddles seem a bit small to me. I've seen on the internet that the paddles for the first and second models are essentially interchangeable, and many who had the first controller swapped out the paddles on the larger original models for the second. While I'm very happy with the size of these paddles, they just don't fit the controller well. They dangle and don't make good contact with the keys. It is possible to press down on the large lower petals and the button does not recognize the press. They may work better on the original Elite controller, but anyone looking for larger paddles for their Elite 2 should look elsewhere.