I will edit this when the replacement arrives but the left boot is noticeably narrower than the right (that's how it should fit). This is the first pair of Sanuks this has happened to, so I'm not disappointed in them. Will definitely keep trying because these shoes are excellent. Edit: I got my new pair and this one actually had underwires which made me feel better even though they didn't have paper like the other pair. . It's weird that it's so different. Both new shoes fit the same and are oversized in the last pair, which is slightly larger than they should be, but they didn't have an 11.5 here. The emblem is just below the heel, which is easy to feel barefoot, but it does wear out. They look great and I hope they last as long as my last pair where my heel pierced the sole after so many years of wearing.
DANSKO Wayne Black Size 11.5-12 Regular
51 Review
53534 Titan Safety Toe Men's Shoes by Timberland PRO
46 Review
Men's Merrell Jungle Waterproof Slip-On Loafers in Gunsmoke - Shoes for Superior Comfort and Style
47 Review
Wool Blend Slippers Heathered Leather Maximum Men's Shoes and Loafers & Slip-Ons
58 Review