Review on Enhance Your Lashes with 4D Silk Fiber Waterproof Mascara - Long Lasting, Smudge-Proof & Natural Curling and Lengthening Mascara - Extra Long and Exquisitely Black by Tracy Thrash

I have reordered this item several times, or at least I thought it was the same item and each time it was a little different. The packaging is always the same - a beautifully iridescent shiny container - but the price, texture and name on the outside were different (see photo). My first purchase was the best. It glides on beautifully, doesn't flake or smear, and washes off easily (a big plus for the medical staff since mascara is the only makeup I wear under a mask and visor). The current product is clumpy, harder to apply and is already flaking off. I have to spend extra time carefully applying it to smooth it out. Overall it stays waterproof as promised and I love how easy it is to wash off. I will probably buy again in the hope of getting a similar product to the first time but it would be nice to know if I am buying the same product from the same company or if they are all different but look the same. .