I'm a long time Allen Edmonds fan. I was very wary of buying a new pair from anyone other than the factory. However, they appear to be in excellent condition. Very happy.
Pros
Unfortunately the sides of the shoes are too high for my husband's ankle. Great price, unfortunately I had to send it back.
Cons
Shoes don't come in different widths, so people with wider or narrower feet will have trouble finding a comfortable fit.