I think I underestimated the 'loose fit' I've got around and it's HUGE. I'll try the small one and see if it fits better. Definitely downsize.
Hanes Sleeve T Shirt Large White Men's Clothing T-Shirts & Tanks: Premium Comfort and Versatile Style
33 Review
AM Fitted T Shirt 3 Pack for Men's Clothing - T-Shirts & Tanks
46 Review
Inkopious DADA T Shirt: A Stylish and Comfortable Father's Crewneck Men's Clothing in T-Shirts & Tanks
32 Review
Ultimate Comfort: Discover the Comfort Colors Sleeve 6014 - X Large Men's Clothing, T-Shirts & Tanks
40 Review