My son is usually a 10.5 and had to return the 9.5 in these - but they fit great! We did a rainforest hike in Puerto Rico and we all had these shoes - comfortable, stepped on and managed mud/water etc great, definitely recommend!
Pros
Has lived up to expectations. Unsurprisingly, it has to meet the basic requirements.
Cons
The material from which the shoes are made tears easily and wears out quickly.