I bought these shoes as an alternative knowing I go to a water park and usually hate water shoes. But in 100 degree weather, with the sun burning concrete all day, I know I want to protect my feet. It was a good alternative. I chose the large size (13) for my foot size 12 2E. It was a bit loose, but luckily the little laces are more than just decoration. They are made of elastic material and sit comfortably on the feet. Everything was true to size and style. The four stars are the answer to the seams that already seem to give way to leather and canvas material. After just a week, I'm worried, but I tend to be rough on my stuff. They are comfortable all day which is a surprise at the water park, I was expecting a few blisters. I would buy again and recommend.