I have not searched for a replacement. The strap appears to be an in-between size. The next size up I feared might just be too big. So I just kept it and still don't wear it. What I find unusual is that the strip of leather (or tongue) that runs after the eyelets (holes) and pointed tip is significantly shorter and would require recalibration. I would still recommend going up the size though.
Spec Ops Brand 100150101 Better Regular Men's Accessories
51 Review
Kenneth Cole REACTION Perfect Adjustable Men's Accessories
56 Review
Experience Lightweight Durability π with Horizon Gunmetal Ultralight Black Strap
54 Review
Nathan Zipster Running Waist Black Men's Accessories
60 Review