Review on Heathen Nation T Shirt 2X Large Military Men's Clothing in Shirts by David Pullen

Bought 2 Heathen Nation t-shirts at once because the reviews were great. It's probably just a personal matter. But they are both made from the same 100/combined cotton. Why is this one as heavy, stiff and uncomfortable as cardboard but the other one is perfect? (Baseball sleeve 3 quarters) Lightweight cotton, soft and conforms to your body. I like the graphics too.