I've barely put this shoe on and it says it's my size (size 12). I had a similar experience with another pair of Rockport Penny Loafers - they seem to me to be a size and a half too small even though the correct size is listed on the shoe. This shoe in particular was particularly ugly. Ugly skin and mediocre workmanship. A few years ago Rockports shoes were of very high quality. They've definitely been cutting corners lately. I will never buy one again.