I wasn't looking for an exchange. The strap seems to be between sizes in it. The next size up I was afraid might be too big. So I just kept it and still don't wear it. What I find unusual is that the strip of leather (or tongue) that runs after the eyelets (holes) and pointed tip is significantly shorter and would require recalibration. I would still recommend going up the size though.
220 Plastic π Collar Stays for Organized Closet
9 Review
π Ultimate Flexibility with Premium Extender Expandable Elastic America Men's Accessories
9 Review
π Premium Plastic Collar Stays - Assorted Sizes in Crisp White Finish
9 Review
𧲠Wurkin Stiffs Plastic Magnetic Men's Accessories and Collar Stays for Stiff N Stay
8 Review