I ordered a belt that matches my actual pant size and it fits really well (the third hole is spot on, there's room to grow!). The material feels like plastic in the hand. , but visually it looks quite nice. I know it's leather, I don't doubt it, it just seems more pliable to me than other smooth leather straps I've had. It's nice and wide, which is great for people who carry a spare tire. If the belt holds up over time I will upgrade to 5 stars later.