Header banner
Revain logoHome Page
Neil Bodell photo
1 Level
1311 Review
69 Karma

Review on uni USB C SD Card Reader Adapter USB 3.0 - Supports SD/Micro SD/SDHC/SDXC/MMC - Compatible with MacBook Pro, MacBook Air, iPad Pro 2018, Galaxy S20, Huawei Mate 30, and More by Neil Bodell

Revainrating 2 out of 5

No read-only support - keep your valuable data away from it at all costs.

Unfortunately, this reader does not support the SD card's write-protect switch (for those who don't know, the write-protection is not controlled in the card itself, instead the switch is a mechanical signal to the reader, controlled via must have an appropriate switch position detection sensor (This reader does not have this sensor) Why it is important If you don't like the nasty surprise of your photos being accidentally destroyed by a device that happens to malfunction with your read/write set map, you have probably learned Keeping memory cards writable only when in the camera and write-protected at all other times. But it doesn't work with this reader. I noticed this design flaw almost as soon as I took it out of the box, but decided to take the risk anyway as I haven't had this issue in years. But once when I tried to connect it to my phone in the field, for some reason the phone couldn't mount it securely and scattered corruption throughout the file system, rendering over a dozen images unreadable. Luckily I've already backed up most of them on my laptop (its built-in card reader, not cheap chinese junk, supports write protection) and only lost one completely, but it was enough that I couldn't risk it. with this thing again. I'm 2 months out of my return window and now I hardly ever use this product. The reason I wanted it was that the USB-C port could be connected to a smartphone without an additional adapter cable, but without write protection I can't trust this use case at all. All of my other computers have card readers built in, and I have a few other USB readers that plug into port A that do not lack this important feature. I'd call it a paperweight, but I don't think it has nearly enough bulk to qualify (so I guess the only good thing I can say about it is that it's light). but without write protection I can't trust this use case at all. All of my other computers have card readers built in, and I have a few other USB readers that plug into port A that do not lack this important feature. I'd call it a paperweight, but I don't think it has nearly enough bulk to qualify (so I guess the only good thing I can say about it is that it's light). but without write protection I can't trust this use case at all. All of my other computers have card readers built in, and I have a few other USB readers that plug into port A that do not lack this important feature. I'd call it a paperweight, but I don't think it has anywhere near enough mass to qualify (so I guess the only good thing I can say about it is,

Pros
  • Electronics
Cons
  • I'll write later