Review on Gray Silicone Protective Accessories 5-Pack for Apple Pencil 1st Generation: Includes 2 Cap Replacements, Cap Holder, Tip Cover, Cable Adapter Tether by Joe Patterson

This is good value for money however the lid retainer will loosen over time and the magnetic lid is not as strong as the second generation replacement lid! I still use the adapter holder cable on both sets I bought but I managed to lose both caps! The material is too thin and will loosen over time or eventually break through the top. I put a round gooey blob on the lid and it's still there somewhere! The most important part, the adapter, has been protected with parts to avoid losing it!