I have bought these shoes 3 times in the last 3 years in different sizes. They look good and will not deteriorate if children scratch them. She also has other shoes, including Sperry and Balleto flats, which "peel" the color after wearing (usually the first time you wear them). My daughter also has narrow feet so the strap and extra liner help keep them snug and longer. I also bought the bootie version of this shoe and they were just as good.
Flexible Comfort: pediped Flex Isabella Mary Jane for Toddlers and Little Kids
47 Review
Dance in Style with Molly Jane Tap Shoes: Unisex-Child Mary Flats
50 Review
Felix Flora Toddler Flower Dress Shoes - Adorable and Comfy Flats
47 Review
DREAM PAIRS Little Aurora 03 Communion Shoes and Flats for Girls - Top Choice for Stunning Style and Comfort
49 Review