The true test is still a long way off, but this particular shoe is very comfortable while walking and is light on the foot. Looks great. If they hold up for years, then we have a winner. Just take a look. Update: A year has passed, the backs have fallen apart. The leather is ok but the fabric materials on the back, tongue and elastic have come loose. Gel memory foam has lost its memory. Damage was visible after 9 months of use. Feel wise, they're still somewhat comfortable, but they're not enough in the long run. I would not recommend it. Now we're looking for something that's as comfortable as new, but much more durable.