I haven't had a cell phone case for a long time, I usually carry my cell phone in my handbag or trouser pocket. I bought the Xr and found that it's a bit larger than I expected and doesn't usually fit in my pocket. I wanted something that would allow me to carry my phone with me without always having to take my purse with me. It really fits the bill. The whole setup is actually a lot thinner than I expected and doesn't stick out too much. I usually wear it on the side of my hip, not on my hip. The phone feels reasonably secure and easily accessible. I am very satisfied with the product so far.