My daughter advised me. It seemed dry so I went to a discount store and bought a new one to see if there was a difference. There was! I wouldn't have done this "experiment" if I hadn't had a recommendation and if I hadn't read about the same problem in another review. The fresh was very good, not lumpy or flaky at all. So my advice is try it at your local store, not online.
Get Bold and Beautiful Lashes with Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara, Blackest Black - 0.32 fl Oz (Packaging May Vary)
97 Review
6 Pack Of Amblyopia Eye Patches For Kids Glasses - Effective Treatment For Lazy Eye And Strabismus, Gentle On Children'S Skin (Pink) By Ewinever(R)
50 Review
Maybelline New York Mascara The Falsies Lash Lift, black
94 Review
NYX professional makeup Palette of shadows Ultimate Shadow Palette Festival 13
42 Review
Unleash Your Inner Unicorn With KARIZMA'S Chunky Holographic Glitter Set - Perfect For Festivals, Raves And Makeup Artistry!
35 Review
Triclosan-Free Clear Liquid Hand Soap Refill, 56 Fluid Ounces, 2-Pack By Amazon Basics - Gentle And Mild
43 Review
Neem And Tea Tree Oil Balm - Soothes And Calms Dry, Itchy Skin Irritation - Oleavine TheraTree
36 Review
π¨ Bioderma Atoderm Cleansing Oil: Ultimate Solution for Very Dry Sensitive Skin
39 Review