Mine was full of scratches, no big deal. but it didn't match my splines on my 2003 f150. The tool sent to me should have fit if the dimensions matched the description. They might fit in a small car with toothed lugs, but definitely not in a light-medium truck. The only thing I can think of is they probably sent me the wrong tool. Anyway, I went the expensive route, broke the studs and replaced them, leaving two more.