not as soft as running shoes that stick out at the back of the heel. So only 4 stars for comfort but I'm giving 5 because it's good enough if you don't have foot problems and it's a great shoe in blue. Therefore 5 stars for the optics. So technically 4.5 stars. if he was a little softer like a wild horse, he would get a 5. Wildpferd trail shoes get 5 stars for the trail - the profile holds up on treacherous paths and the cushioning is amazing, even mine that I've worn are still good.