This was the perfect size replacement for my Garmin 230. It also fits the 235 perfectly. The material is softer and won't tear like the original Garmin straps. The screws are the same high test screws, not cheap replacements. I would put 5 but I'm used to the original material of the bracelet. I tried two of the original straps and they lasted longer than either. It's also less than half the price!