The case looks very nice. The original parts of the controller fit, except for the ring on the outside of the XBox home button, so I ended up using the one that came with the new skin. Some of the plastic edges needed to be scraped off with a utility knife, but other than that I'm very happy with the overall look. Pros: Affordable, durable, good fit. Installation of the part requires some work The knobs that come with it don't look as nice as the original