I love these ProClub t-shirts for their quality and the tight, thick collars, but compared to the older ProClub Comfort t-shirts, this t-shirt feels more like sandpaper. Even my no-frills FOL and Hanes bottoms are more comfortable. However, there is no doubt that these ProClubs are sturdy and have a collar that stays in place - I'm a bit disappointed with the latter. Only 3 stars for that.