Review on DNM Nude Matte Lipstick and Lip Liner Set: 6Pcs Makeup Kit for Black Mature Women - Waterproof, Long Lasting & 24H Stay by Randy Olson

I was very disappointed in them. I didn't open until the return window opened, otherwise I would have sent them back. Most of the liners were broken, they came straight out of the tube and some of the lipsticks and liners smelled awful. As if they were super old! It was a waste of money. The colors were gorgeous but how could I wear them when they smelled so bad and couldn't use most liners!