Great shoes, fit great. I didn't give it 5 stars because the right boot was clearly a boot sample (there were some wrinkles already).

A little snugger than I expected but one day they are very comfortable. They would be perfect if it wasn't for my mallet finger.

A great choice for lazy guys who still turn lace-ups into flip-flops. They were small but will stretch over time. Seems well done. I hope they last longer than Nunn Bush flip flops which wear out in less than 10 months.

I've been a long time fan of Cole Haan and especially these Nantuckets as they are durable, chunky and look great with so many outfits. I bought them for around $40 and I can easily say they are a steal and I love wearing them every day. The logo on the back of the sole was something the previous Nantuckets didn't have as far as I can remember, but that doesn't bother me.

This is a great pair of shoes. The only downside is that after a month and a half of wearing, the skin darkened and the lining of the logo on the heel peeled off. It seems very easy to carry.

I wear an 8 or 8.5 for Nike and a 39 or 40 for ECCO. 7.5 is perfect for me. Very light and stylish shoes. Look at the photos. The product is only available in one style, limiting its versatility.

I wear a size 10 and ordered a size 10.5. I couldn't put my foot in the shoe. I had to go back. They seem to be made for small, narrow feet.

This is my second pair of these loafers. They are very good but the last one was sent to me a size larger than what I bought. :-(

Great shoes, stylish and practical. I've ridden them many miles and they last. After a while I had to add insoles to support the arch but the shoes are well made and last a long time. I now have 3 pairs.

I wear a 12, bought a size 12. It just wasn't good. too tight and the back of the boot cut into my heel. To return. If you're a sensitive little European man, maybe you can wear this.

The Cole Haan Nantucket II is comfortable to wear and fits well. It combines the comfort and durability of a sports shoe sole with the casual style of classic penny loafers. My only complaint is the lack of bow support. I bought a pair of lightweight orthotics and put them in my shoes, which solved this problem. All in all I love the shoes so much that I bought the same model in three different colors.

This is the second pair my husband has bought in this style. The other pair is dark blue. He says they're very comfortable, go with everything but clothes, and have a stylish "look". The size fits perfectly, soft leather hugs the leg. He is very happy with these shoes.

My work has recently shifted from business casual to smart casual, which means jeans, a collared shirt and shoes instead of sneakers. Instead of wearing my fancy shoes with jeans, I bought them to be comfortable and make HR happy. These are fantastic shoes, very comfortable and fit as expected for my size. The ONLY downside to these boots (guaranteed not to drop a star) is that when wet the leather will turn dark brown for about 15 minutes until the water has evaporated. It's not that bad, but…