🌿 Half Caked Totally Tubular Mascara - Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Flake-Free, Smudge-Free, Clean Beauty Formula - Easy-to-Remove - 8.5ml (The Dream) Review

I've been using waterproof mascara for at least 30 years. This formula was usually the only thing that didn't typically smear, flake, or straighten my lashes (which I have to curl). This tubular mascara is amazing. It holds my curls and doesn't flake or smear. And it is very easy to remove just with warm water. Love the product and love that you can choose what kind of wand you want.

Originally got this in my Ipsy Gam+ bag and it was great! There are no lumps, lies flat. So I bought a new pipe from Revain. Comes in big chunks. You have to rub the spiral around the edge of the tube to apply it. It will still go smooth if you wipe up the clumps. But it's a waste of ink.

From the first use this mascara delivered in every way: real mascara, volume and length, won't fade curls and really washes out with warm water and toner. easy. But overnight it dried up and changed texture and after the first use it's not the same. I kept using it for a couple of weeks but now it has started to crumble and come off for the rest of the day, basically getting worse every day. Won't redeem, but that's a shame because it started great.