This one held my things the best as I still carry a check book. The only thing I would change would be to have an exterior coin pocket the length of the wallet with a clasp rather than interior one with a zipper. There is a also a zipper on the compartment that contains the coin pocket. I would prefer not to have any zippers and prefer clasps. But hey, finding one that holds all my cards and a check book! I am thrilled! I would never buy a wallet as gift because if my own requirements so could…