I've purchased these boots in both brown and black and I'm pleased with both pair. I have plantar fasciitis and I'm able to wear these all day without my feet hurting. The black pair are smaller in the calf than the brown. Luckily I have small calves, but if they were any larger they wouldn't fit. They look nice and not cheap made. That was a nice surprise given the price. You definitely can't beat them for the price. The only reason I have 4 stars instead of 5 is the narrow calf in the black…

I am not usually one to wear flats, but these are really cute and stylish. Even though they're not leather, they don't look or feel cheap.

Thick socks and a gel insert. Bought a half size too big, should have bought at least 1/2, if not an entire size. Thanks for attention.

I ordered a 9 1/2 when I usually wear a 10. They are still quite loose. I like the look though, and generally when buying boots the part around the calf is way too big. These are pretty perfect in that regard. I have muscular calves, but not big enough for most boots that tend to be too big in that area. If you're on the fence, I'd say buy these. but size down.