For the dress I purchased this slip for, it didn't work as it was too long. However, I wanted the slip to poof the dress and it didn't poof. The slip was lumpy. I tried to fluff the slip (have worked in a bridal store so I know a thing or two about getting a crinoline slip to behave.)If you're wearing slip for a costume or a fun run, I think it could work. However, bunching the slip up or rolling it up wasn't an option since it would have punched around hips. Not for me, keep in mind what you'reSee full review