Definitely downsize. Couldn't get stuck again in a shirt my husband can't wear. On the other hand, it's a nice color, well-tailored and beautiful shirt. I would downsize. Broken down so it doesn't fit.
Van Heusen Traveler Stretch Men's Shirt
47 Review
Gildan Performance Men's π Clothing and Shirts with Moisture-Wicking Polyester
44 Review
H2H Mens Casual Slim Fit Short Sleeve T-Shirts Cotton Blended Soft Lightweight V-Neck/Crew-Neck
46 Review
Calvin Klein π Herringbone Sleeve Men's Dress Clothing
50 Review