It fits my controller well, not too loose. Though I had to keep adjusting the holes around the thumbsticks - my left stick would get stuck to the lid if I pushed it too far left (hard to avoid if you're moving the character left). I was about to cut a hole around the left stick when I noticed black marks from the cover on my fingers. Instead I'm sending it back.
Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller Adapter for Windows 10
23 Review
Classic Sonic Collectible Cable Guy Device Holder: Compatible with PlayStation, Xbox, and Smartphones - Perfect for Gamers!
13 Review
Microsoft Xbox 360 Controller for Windows Bundle
190 Review
Gamepad Microsoft Xbox 360 Wireless Controller for Windows, black
34 Review