Update: It has been 4 months since installation and the paint on the left ring is starting to peel off. Not very durable. These rings are easy to remove, but you still need to be careful. I will be returning the original rings and discarding this product. It was pretty easy to replace. I have experience disassembling consoles so your mile may vary. I would just be cautious about taking the old ones out so you can put them back in for whatever reason. The change looks minor, but I think it would be even better on a black or red controller.