Apparently they send random shirts. Mine were the right size and color. They don't appear to be defective at first glance, except that 5 are missing. A few threads protrude from the seams, but no more than I would expect from cheap t-shirts. The ones I received are thick Gildan cotton from Haiti.
π Nantersan Placket Raglan Tee - A Casual Must-Have
52 Review
Calvin Klein π Herringbone Sleeve Men's Dress Clothing
50 Review
Gildan Performance Men's π Clothing and Shirts with Moisture-Wicking Polyester
44 Review
INFLATION Bamboo Shirts Sleeve Elastic Men's Clothing in Shirts
45 Review