Review on Goodthreads Long Sleeve Lightweight Henley X Large Men's Clothing for Shirts by Bishop Terry

I wear a shirt with collar 17 and sleeve 34, which usually fits size XL. The "classic" cut of the shirt is very loose in the waist, and I usually choose something slightly fitted. I ordered this Henley in size XL. It had the right sleeve and torso length, but was too tight. It looks like it was made for someone who is low on fat and doesn't work. Unfortunately, I have a bit of both and ended up gifting it to my dad.