Review on Fosmon [Set of 4] Xbox One Analog Stick Joystick Controller Extended Thumb Grips for Enhanced Performance in Solid Black by Tammy Reeves

I bought these to replace the original thumb grip on my Xbox One X controller. It fits over the analog stick but is loose. The handle is made of hard plastic and moves around the racket as you play. It's a hard plastic, not dense rubber, which means it's much easier to tear than rubber. It's just not a quality product. If you really need a holder you can buy this one until you find a better one, but even using the analog without a handle is way better than this product. I would avoid that in the future.