I'm rating this 1 to 3 stars. The seller sent replacement tights which my daughter has worn a couple of times and have not torn. They are warm and she finds them comfortable. The fabric rolls a little. I would recommend getting a size larger than the size chart, but I almost always find this with tights. My initial review: My daughter only wore them for about ten minutes before she developed a large hole in the crotch area. Very disappointed with the quality.