the first one worked well for about 5 days and then caused uncontrollable up and down movements when playing. The problem got progressively worse over the course of a few days so I sent the faulty controller back and they sent me another one. the same thing happens with the second. That something related to the left manipulator gets very tricky. It works well for the first five days and then starts making uncontrollable movements. It doesn't cost $18. I've also tried this on multiple computers and the same thing happens on each of them. So it's not my computer.