I just took these shoes and tried them on. They fit great and feel very comfortable. They appear to be well made and everything seems fine. I'm not sure everyone gets the same thing, but I really don't see what's wrong with that at all. that it's plastic, but they're wrong. It's definitely leather. Someone else said they didn't like the color but ordered it anyway so how can the color not be like this? They cannot be worn every day. This is more for the weekend and while you relax. I just don't understand what the heck they are complaining about because these are great shoes at a great price! You would think they would do their homework before buying! 5 stars in everything!