We bought a lot of Fluff and Tuff toys for our 20 lb Boston Terrier mix. Most of the toys we bought remained intact except for minor repairs. Mister Sloth was dismantled in less than an hour; Face, hands and squeaker were on the floor. This toy is not as durable as other F&T toys. The fabric, stitching and tweeter pouch separated with little resistance. For comparison: Rocket Raccoon still beeps after 2 years. Horse, elephant, monkey, alligator, elephant do not creak, but are intact. I wonder if there is another toy manufacturer?