Received the belt today and while it doesn't exactly match the advertised Florsheim wingtips (I have a pair) it's close enough. It feels well made and attractive, and I love the perforations that match the shoes. But it doesn't say "leather" anywhere, and I'm wondering if it really is leather. Seems plastic. If so, then this is indeed false advertising and Revane should be ashamed. Hence the 3 stars.