Looking at the cartridge contacts they don't seem to have the gold sheen on the contacts. This will make the connection to the printer bad if the contacts are even slightly corroded. By gently rubbing with an eraser to clean the contacts, the printer was able to detect a previously defective cartridge.
Cartridge NV Print CE285A for HP LaserJet Pro P1102/P1102w/M1132/M1212nf/M1217, black
13 Review
4-Pack Toner Bank Compatible Replacement for Brother TN760 TN-760 TN730 TN-730 Black Toner Cartridge for MFC-L2710DW DCP-L2550DW HL-L2350DW HL-L2390DW MFC-L2750DW HL-L2395DW HL-L2370DW Printer Ink
11 Review
Brother TN436BK Super High Yield Toner, Black - Retail Packaging
11 Review
Inkjet MFP HP Ink Tank Wireless 419, color, A4, black
52 Review