After reading the previous reviews I decided to go a little larger than what I am used to. Since I'm a size 10 1/2, I chose an 11. They felt a bit tight at first but now that I've been wearing them for about a month they have stretched and fit my foot perfectly. They are definitely the most comfortable pair I have ever had. I was pleasantly surprised at how good they are. It was nice to find them in the "wide" size, although I'm curious if the first mistake is because I ripped off the boot (which usually happens to me). So if you are planning to buy them I would say go for a slightly larger size!