Turns out I bought a European adult size which is not the US size I thought I was getting.
There was a size comparison in the shoe box which would have been helpful before I bought the shoes.
TSLA Lightweight Athletic Barefoot Minimalist Men's Shoes for Athletic
74 Review
Joomra Barefoot Minimalist Athletic Breathable Men's Shoes
73 Review
Saucony Mens Peregrine Sneaker Black Men's Shoes
65 Review
Chaco π£ Z2 Classic Stepped Sandal
71 Review
π Nike React Element Bq6166 008 Black: Enhanced Performance and Sleek Design
4 Review
π Explore Top-Notch Comfort with New Balance 990V5 Sneaker Castlerock
3 Review
π Iconic Sneaker for Men by New Balance
5 Review
π New Balance Men's Iconic Sneaker Shoes for Men