I've been using the Mayflash PS3 Adapter for almost 2 years and it works great with no problems. The only thing I didn't like about the other adapter was that it only worked with short charging cables and didn't charge the controller when using a longer one. I bought this adapter thinking I could use my longer cable. As expected, it charges my controller with a longer cable, but that's where my enjoyment ends. The adapter randomly disconnects your controller and reconnects it to another player. The lights on the controller will not flash while charging to show you the charge level. When connected to the adapter, the left analog stick randomly drags left and right. The analog stick slowly moves to the right. When I use the Mayflash PS3 adapter on PC or use the controller on my PS3 I have no problems only when I use this Magic S Pro adapter.