I bought this a year ago so my thoughts aren't to open the box and rejoice that something has arrived and got all 5 stars for having arrived and "looks good". I love the reversibility of the strap and you can trim it down to the perfect length, but my 3 star rating is because it looks like a dog towards the end of the strap where it repeatedly "hooks" into my special strap hole chewed on it. The surface looks worn. The old leather strap that should be replaced (it's OLO OLD OLD) looks better and I'm still using it. So 3 is generous.