I bought these loafers for my stepdad and he loves them. They're a little tight, but now that he's broken them in he finds them comfortable. He loves them because they don't have the fluffy lining that many loafers have. In these shoes he lives outside of work, and in the warm season he does not need a fluffy lining. The orange peg on the back of the shoes looks a bit odd, but the soles have good grip and are comfortable to walk on. My stepdad likes them so much that I was advised to get him more for his birthday and Christmas. . I like that they are about the same price as I usually buy at retail and the quality is better than what we buy at Walmart or Target. 4.5 stars (Half a star went for the bright orange cork on the back of the shoe.)