this one gets 5 stars, I'll buy another one, but only because I've heard from other reviews that I buy at least one or two sizes must high. I usually wear a medium size but I bought a very large size for this and you can see it fits like a regular medium shirt in the photo. I'm glad I saw the other reviews! Also, the shirt is comfortable and looks good enough for me to buy a second one. I'm 5ft 11in and about 190lbs.