Well I like the stand and it would have a 5 star rating but I'm not sure if I got a new one or not. The product came in the most amazing packaging, would remind you of Apple. but there are tiny scratches on the front of the stand frame around the ipad, it is not smooth as you would expect something brand new. Also the part that the card actually goes through is not good for plastic. You can pinch the back of this part and the plastic will stick out at least 1 or 2mm and you can see that it's not flush with the rest of the stand. The stitching should be in place as with the rest of the stand. .But that's not the case. Would love to trade it in and try a different stand, maybe I have one to send right now?